Zap Info News is an independent financial comparison platform. We may earn a commission when you click through.
Debt Consolidation Loans Compared: Five Bank Options
HSBC allows borrowing up to £30,000, while Halifax no longer accepts new loan applications. Compare terms before applying.
Quick Picks
Best overall: HSBC Personal Loan for Debt Consolidation.
Best budget: NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan.
Best for existing Lloyds customers: Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan.
Debt consolidation can simplify several payments into one, but a lower monthly bill does not automatically mean a lower total cost. The term, rate, fees and the amount you actually borrow matter more than the headline payment.
Rates and terms shown are representative. Your actual rate depends on your credit profile and circumstances. This is not financial advice — always read the lender's terms before applying.
Large borrowing and fast decisions
The first group is for borrowers who need a meaningful loan amount and want a clear repayment structure. HSBC is the most detailed option in the supplied data; Barclays is less transparent here because the available page extract does not show its rate, fee or loan-limit terms.
What should you check before consolidating?
List every debt, its balance, interest rate and remaining term. Then compare the new loan's total repayable amount with the cost of keeping the existing accounts. A longer term can reduce the monthly payment while increasing the interest paid.
HSBC Personal Loan for Debt Consolidation
HSBC is the strongest all-round pick in this comparison because the published page gives a usable borrowing range of £1,000 to £30,000 and fixed monthly payments. The term runs up to 60 months for loans up to £15,000 and up to 96 months above that threshold, giving borrowers room to manage a larger consolidation balance. HSBC also states that applicants can receive an instant decision and access funds quickly after the signed agreement is received. That speed is useful, but it should not push you into borrowing before checking the total repayment. The supplied data does not show the representative APR, origination fee, late-payment charge or eligibility threshold, so those figures must be confirmed directly with HSBC. Compared with Barclays, HSBC gives much more concrete information in the available listing. Best for a borrower consolidating several debts into one fixed-payment loan who needs up to £30,000 and values a quick decision.
Barclayloan Debt Consolidation
Barclays belongs in the comparison, but the available product extract is thin: it identifies the Barclayloan debt-consolidation page without exposing a rate, borrowing range, term, fee schedule or approval timing. That makes a direct cost comparison impossible from the supplied evidence. I would not choose it solely because the product is branded for debt consolidation; the key question is the personalised APR and total amount repayable after application. Ask Barclays whether it can settle creditors directly, whether early repayment is free, and whether any existing overdraft or card balances are excluded from the application. HSBC is easier to assess at this stage because its range and repayment periods are published. Barclays may still suit an existing customer who receives a materially lower personalised rate, but the numbers need to justify switching. Best for an existing Barclays customer who can verify the full quote before accepting and whose debts fit the lender's eligibility rules.
HSBC wins on published detail and speed, while Barclays requires more homework before you can judge value. Neither should be assessed by the monthly payment alone. According to HSBC's personal-loan page, the maximum term depends on the amount borrowed; that threshold can materially change the total interest bill.
Established-bank alternatives for simpler repayments
NatWest and Lloyds frame consolidation around reducing the number of payments. That can make household budgeting easier, but the benefit only holds if you close or control the old credit accounts rather than rebuilding the balances.
Does one monthly payment always save money?
No. A single payment may improve cash flow without reducing the total cost. Compare the existing debts' remaining interest with the new loan's total repayable figure, and include any settlement or early-repayment charges attached to the old borrowing.
NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan
NatWest makes the purpose of the product unusually clear: its page says borrowers could pay less each month with one simple payment. That is a useful budgeting benefit, but the wording is not a promise of a lower total cost or approval. The supplied extract does not show the representative APR, maximum loan amount, term, late fee or early-repayment terms, so those details should be requested before applying. Compared with HSBC, NatWest has less visible numerical detail here but may appeal to someone whose main problem is juggling several due dates. The right test is simple: write down the current monthly payments, then compare them with the proposed NatWest payment and total repayable amount. Do not extend the term merely to create spare cash unless the budget genuinely requires it. Best for a borrower with multiple unsecured debts who wants one scheduled payment and will check the full personalised quote before accepting.
Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan
Lloyds is a sensible comparison for borrowers already familiar with the bank, but the supplied page content does not reveal a rate, loan range, term, fee structure or approval time. That missing information matters more than the product label. Existing Lloyds customers should still compare the new quote against their current card and loan rates, because loyalty does not guarantee the cheapest borrowing. Ask specifically about the total amount repayable, early settlement, missed-payment consequences and whether the lender permits extra payments without a charge. NatWest provides a similar one-payment rationale, while HSBC offers the clearest published range and term structure in this set. Lloyds becomes more persuasive only if the personalised quote is lower or the application is materially easier for the applicant's circumstances. Best for an existing Lloyds customer with several debts who can verify the APR, total cost and repayment term before consolidating.
Halifax Debt Consolidation Loan
Halifax should not be treated as a live fifth application route. Its page states that, because the Halifax brand is changing to Lloyds, new Halifax loan applications are no longer available and directs applicants to Lloyds loans instead. Existing Halifax borrowers keep their loans under the Halifax brand, according to the supplied page content, but that is different from being able to take out a new consolidation loan. This is the most important practical finding in the comparison: a product can appear in search results while no longer accepting new applications. Anyone comparing Halifax should move straight to the Lloyds page and request current terms rather than relying on an old Halifax illustration. Best for existing Halifax loan customers checking their current account status, not for someone seeking a new debt-consolidation application.
Comparison table
The table separates verified facts from information that is absent in the supplied listings. Treat blank rate and fee fields as questions to ask the lender, not as evidence that charges do not apply. Official pages should be checked immediately before an application because loan terms can change.
| Loan | Published borrowing detail | Repayment information | Decision or access | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HSBC Personal Loan | £1,000–£30,000 | Up to 60 months for loans up to £15,000; up to 96 months above £15,000 | Instant decision; quick access after signed agreement | Large consolidation balances and clear published structure |
| Barclayloan | Not shown in supplied extract | Not shown in supplied extract | Not shown in supplied extract | Existing Barclays customers who verify a competitive quote |
| NatWest Debt Consolidation Loan | Not shown in supplied extract | One simple payment promoted | Not shown in supplied extract | Borrowers focused on payment simplicity |
| Lloyds Bank Debt Consolidation Loan | Not shown in supplied extract | Not shown in supplied extract | Not shown in supplied extract | Existing Lloyds customers comparing a personalised quote |
| Halifax Debt Consolidation Loan | New applications unavailable | Existing loans remain Halifax | New applicants directed to Lloyds | Existing Halifax borrowers checking their loan |
None of the supplied listings provides enough fee information to claim that any option is fee-free. Check for arrangement fees, late-payment charges, early-repayment rules and the total amount repayable. A debt-advice service may be more appropriate than a new loan if repayments are already unaffordable.
Choose HSBC if you need up to £30,000 and want the clearest published borrowing and term structure; choose NatWest for payment simplicity only after checking the total cost. Lloyds is the relevant successor route for new Halifax applicants, while Barclays remains a quote-dependent comparison rather than an obvious winner. For a broader method for comparing rates, terms and affordability, read Finding the Best Personal Loan for You in October.